Shotokan's Secret Book Club

This is the area where registered users can create new topics. I keep the other forums locked down, but this one is for you. -- Hanshi Clayton
Forum rules
I reserve the right to delete posts that I find offensive or objectionable. Other than that, have fun. -- Hanshi Clayton

Shotokan's Secret Book Club

Postby colinwee » Sat Feb 07, 2009 10:40 pm

I thought that given this was on topic, a Shotokan's Secret Book Club may be good in order that we can discuss various sections and how they relate to our various styles and schools.

So welcome to the Shotokan's Secret Book Club. This part of the forum makes it easier to provide comment on the book and provide your feedback to Shotokan Research. If you don't have the book handy, I assume the other parts of the forum can jog your memory - or in time my own postings may prompt you along. Whatever it is, you are invited to add your two cents worth - share your own experience and knowledge and open up areas of the book that make sense to you and your style. Or dispute my own claims! I'm happy to have my contributions yay-ed or nay-ed. Be gentle on me! :-)

Hopefully this is in line with what Dr Clayton is intending for his forum.

Regards, Colin
Last edited by colinwee on Tue Feb 10, 2009 4:13 pm, edited 2 times in total.
--
Colin Wee is the Principal of Joong Do Kwan in Western Australia, and a Board Member of AMAHOF Inc. Colin has recently published Breaking Through: The Secrets of Bassai Dai Kata. He has practiced three systems in three countries for four decades.
colinwee
Godan
Godan
 
Posts: 37
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:52 pm
Location: Perth, Western Australia

Re: Shotokan's Secret Book Club

Postby colinwee » Sat Feb 07, 2009 11:06 pm

Let me open this up.

I saw two or three email broadcasts in total promoting the book though I admit I was totally intrigued by the first one I received. I saved the information and read it at least a few times before ordering the book several months later. What caught me wasn't so much the title but that the accompanying text seemed to indicate some level of thought and diligence went into actual research and actual logic to accompany what appeared at the time to be a stupendous claim - that anyone was able to explain "where karate really came from and what its purpose truly is."

I was also drawn to the statement about shotokan being "obsessed with multiple-enemy scenarios". I hugely identified with this statement because of own experience and research over the years had made me hyper-aware of certain things, and this in turn substantially drove my own practice.

Lastly, I've got to say that the title is pretty catchy. Shotokan's Secret indicates that there is some hidden meaning and something that hasn't been revealed. This is totally in line with my own training and my own appreciation of martial knowledge - something that has been my own bugbear throughout the years. As I do pushup after pushup and kick after kick it has taken me such a long time to gain even a small iota of understanding and to internalise this knowledge. I was adamant that something was indeed wrong with the system; rather than wrong with my own perspective. Nowadays as I train students I'd rather tell them more about what they are doing rather than less upfront. This helps drive their own appreciation of training and to help them make their own mind up about the world around them.

Colin
--
Colin Wee is the Principal of Joong Do Kwan in Western Australia, and a Board Member of AMAHOF Inc. Colin has recently published Breaking Through: The Secrets of Bassai Dai Kata. He has practiced three systems in three countries for four decades.
colinwee
Godan
Godan
 
Posts: 37
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:52 pm
Location: Perth, Western Australia

Re: Shotokan's Secret Book Club

Postby HanshiClayton » Sun Feb 08, 2009 11:12 pm

Hi, Colin. Yes, it is on topic. Thanks for starting this thread.

I have to tell you about the title, though. The editors and I tried out over 80 titles. Writing a new title for a "Shotokan" book is hard. They have all been used.

Also, it can't be too long, or too wordy, or too obscure ("Ivanhoe"). It has to be intriguing. It must have the power to make a bookstore patron pull the book off the shelf to open it. :roll: I had no idea it would be so hard to come up with a title that the publisher would run with.

Shotokan's Secret

At least it alliterates.

My title was The Shuri Crucible, which was everything a book title should not be.

The first edition of Shotokan's Secret turns out to be the first half of the story. As you can see from the bunkai forums here, I have finished the second half of the story. I know what the Heians were about. More importantly, I know why they suppressed the applications. Once you see the overall syllabus, it is very plain.
Bruce D. Clayton, Ph.D.
Copyright © 2012, All Rights Reserved.
This forum is supported by the sales of Shotokan's Secret, Expanded Edition
HanshiClayton
Site Founder
Site Founder
 
Posts: 298
Joined: Thu Dec 18, 2008 5:45 pm

Re: Shotokan's Secret Book Club

Postby colinwee » Mon Feb 09, 2009 7:57 pm

KyoshiClayton wrote:My title was The Shuri Crucible, which was everything a book title should not be.


Yeah, I'm not sure if I'd have been as excited with that title. The Shotokan's Secret had enough gumption to do the trick.

The first edition of Shotokan's Secret turns out to be the first half of the story. As you can see from the bunkai forums here, I have finished the second half of the story. I know what the Heians were about. More importantly, I know why they suppressed the applications. Once you see the overall syllabus, it is very plain.


It almost sounds like you're trying to convert me ...

I faced very much the same journey in 2002-2004, then finding myself putting a lot of my thoughts into a manuscript. I took a good year to finish that, but when I was done, I found out that what I produced was only the overview. It has taken me since then to flesh out my own syllabus. It's been painstaking - I had to draw a lot of figures sequencing out drills and applications.

Back to the book ...

I'd typically skip the Introduction of most martial arts books (in fact I had already skipped the Acknowledgements, About the Author, and the San Ten Sensei sections). I had a student once purchase a book on kicking by some famous Korean master, only to find to his dismay that the first 30 odd pages were filled with personal pictures of the guy with celebrities/dignitaries and performing kicks shirtless!

Shotokan's Secret however had an introduction written like one of the problem statements I faced whilst doing my Masters of Business coursework. Surely this wasn't some karate instructor trying to take on more than he can chew? That's refreshing. Someone who was ready to think independently and creatively about martial arts. Grudgingly, I admit the author is onto something and I scan the 'Author' and 'San Ten Sensei' section again before jumping into the book.
--
Colin Wee is the Principal of Joong Do Kwan in Western Australia, and a Board Member of AMAHOF Inc. Colin has recently published Breaking Through: The Secrets of Bassai Dai Kata. He has practiced three systems in three countries for four decades.
colinwee
Godan
Godan
 
Posts: 37
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:52 pm
Location: Perth, Western Australia

Re: Shotokan's Secret Book Club

Postby colinwee » Fri Feb 13, 2009 7:03 am

You know, I've heard a lot of bulls*** about the martial arts ever since joining the martial arts - and I still hear it every so often. One of the best lies is that an art, such as the one I practice, has been in existence for 2000 years! It's refreshing to open a book and read something like this ...

"Hard-style karate was invented in the mid 1800s by the bodyguards to the king of Okinawa."

Now, that's different.

There are several key words that come out of that sentence alone, but the main thing beyond the specific date is that karate was identified as a system used by bodyguards.

How does this place your own practice? Do you use flippity flip techniques? Do you bounce here and there with your opponent? Would this work as bodyguarding skills?

Colin
--
Colin Wee is the Principal of Joong Do Kwan in Western Australia, and a Board Member of AMAHOF Inc. Colin has recently published Breaking Through: The Secrets of Bassai Dai Kata. He has practiced three systems in three countries for four decades.
colinwee
Godan
Godan
 
Posts: 37
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:52 pm
Location: Perth, Western Australia

Re: Shotokan's Secret Book Club

Postby HanshiClayton » Mon Feb 16, 2009 11:06 am

What's a flippity-flip technique?

Here on the border between karate and jujutsu (in the most inclusive sense) the "bodyguard" applications are the ones that combine the two disciplines into the truly vicious "twist and shout" techniques. The karate lets you intercept the attack; the jujutsu lets you twist the enemy into some helpless position; and then the karate lets you ruin him. Some of the techniques would never be sanctioned by modern law. They aren't so much self-defense as they are summary execution.

And unarmed bodyguards would fight like that because the were out-weaponed and out-numbered, and they had to even the odds quickly. Therefore our adherence to the Waldow Principle, which holds that the "correct" application will not be harmless. It will do enough damage to put the enemy out of the fight.

No flippity-flip techniques. ;-) More like flippity-crunch or flippity-snap!
Bruce D. Clayton, Ph.D.
Copyright © 2012, All Rights Reserved.
This forum is supported by the sales of Shotokan's Secret, Expanded Edition
HanshiClayton
Site Founder
Site Founder
 
Posts: 298
Joined: Thu Dec 18, 2008 5:45 pm

Re: Shotokan's Secret Book Club

Postby Philip Sneyd » Tue Jan 05, 2010 1:04 am

I understand what Kyoshi Clayton means, that from a marketing perspective "The Shuri Crucible" is not so good (to attract an unfamiliar public), but I have to admit that I think it sounds cool, and after reading the book, very fitting.

Perhaps the new book could be called "Shotokan's Secret 2: The Shuri Crucible". I am kidding - I know it's a second edition, not a sequel, but "The Shuri Crucible" has a kind of movie title ring to it, doesn't it?

What do you think Dr Clayton? A movie based on factual events about the origins of karate in Okinawa might make for compelling viewing - possible future project you might be interested in? :)
 
Philip is an Irishman based in Japan, where he has been living and training in Kyokushinkai Karate for almost 10 years. He holds a shodan 1st degree black belt and opened a small branch dojo in Tokyo in 2009. He is a big fan of the book Shotokan's Secret.
Philip Sneyd
Shodan
Shodan
 
Posts: 13
Joined: Sun Jan 03, 2010 8:00 am

Re: Shotokan's Secret Book Club

Postby HanshiClayton » Tue Jan 05, 2010 11:23 am

If you want to play with the movie idea, ask yourself what actors you would cast? I'm having a little trouble picturing Jackie Chan as Matsumura. He might make a good Itosu, though.

The historical circumstances of Perry's visit to Okinawa provide a fertile background to a Shogun-like movie or mini-series. There could be some really nasty fights that everyone covered up in order to save face. Maybe that's why Perry ordered his officers to stop making personal journal entries!

I want to play Bettleheim, the scheming missionary.

BDC
Bruce D. Clayton, Ph.D.
Copyright © 2012, All Rights Reserved.
This forum is supported by the sales of Shotokan's Secret, Expanded Edition
HanshiClayton
Site Founder
Site Founder
 
Posts: 298
Joined: Thu Dec 18, 2008 5:45 pm

Re: Shotokan's Secret Book Club

Postby Philip Sneyd » Tue Jan 05, 2010 10:21 pm

I think in his younger years Toshiro Mifune could have been excellent in the role of Sokon Matsumura, but I can't think of a modern, recognizable actor.
 
I know a lot of Japanese film and TV actors who would be great in certain roles, but they might be virtually unknown in America.

As for recognizable names in Hollywood, how about Chow Yun Fat as Kong Sang Kun, Pat Morita (Mr Miyagi) as the Regent Sho Taimu, Jet Li and Ken Watanabe as some of the major Peichin, and Russell Crowe as Commodore Perry?

If I was allowed to be in the film, ideally I'd love to play one of the Okinawans (so I could do some karate :) ) but even with makeup/prosthetics it probably wouldn't be convincing (too much of a gaijin) and hardly worth it. I'd be happy to play one of Perry's men, and perhaps help as an interpreter between the American and Japanese cast on the set.

"You might say I'm a dreamer. But I'm not the only one" ;)    
Philip is an Irishman based in Japan, where he has been living and training in Kyokushinkai Karate for almost 10 years. He holds a shodan 1st degree black belt and opened a small branch dojo in Tokyo in 2009. He is a big fan of the book Shotokan's Secret.
Philip Sneyd
Shodan
Shodan
 
Posts: 13
Joined: Sun Jan 03, 2010 8:00 am

Re: Shotokan's Secret Book Club

Postby colinwee » Wed Feb 10, 2010 7:44 pm

Matsumura? Sounds like a job for Willem Dafoe. He's wiry, and has a mean and crazy look. Check him out on Spiderman 1 http://spiderman.sonypictures.com/movies/spiderman/photogallery/stills/?p=2.
--
Colin Wee is the Principal of Joong Do Kwan in Western Australia, and a Board Member of AMAHOF Inc. Colin has recently published Breaking Through: The Secrets of Bassai Dai Kata. He has practiced three systems in three countries for four decades.
colinwee
Godan
Godan
 
Posts: 37
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:52 pm
Location: Perth, Western Australia

Next

Return to Roundtable Forum

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

cron
Hit Counter by Digits