gilliancompo wrote:I no longer hit a makiwara or break boards, but I do still strive to punch a hole in a newspaper, if anyone would care to elaborate on the mechanics of that type of punch?
If you're talking about a reverse snap punch, the deceleration of the punching arm coincides with the instantaneous shifting of the centre of gravity into the front foot, the vibration of the hip forward, and the tensioning of the abdominal muscles to 'transmit' the power generated from the lower body into the upper body. The punching arm is linked to the body via the lats, and the upper body is 'tensioned' so that the rotational movement occurs as 'a system' (further increasing the mass supporting the striking tool). The punching hand is rotated palm down because ... well, if you were to support your weight on a table in front of you, you would place your palm down and lock the arm in place. The punching hand turned down allows you to 'drop' your weight into it.
I know I could do it well, but again I do not recall hips being involved, only the thought in my mind of penetrating the newspaper, being totally relaxed except for my fist and thus punching faster than I have ever punch in my life, due to my relaxed body condition.
Tom, even noted I have a strong punch, right Tom?
At a basic level, we look at linear lunging acceleration, hip rotation, and shoulder rotation to drive punching power. The hip rotation or 'vibration' is a concept that can of course be done with more subtlety. So if an expert such as yourself has learned how to punch using the body's core - then you've just dispensed with that module of the basics that uses overt hip rotation to generate such power.
That leads me to a question on the candle punching, can a tense person punch out a flame or does it take a relaxed body, or how cares, or is it more to do with the wind?
I think the relaxed body accelerates the punch more effectively. A larger stronger person doesn't need this ... they just use their tree trunk arms to kill you. Smaller people need coordination in order to use the entire body at once.
Your use of the word “pulse” make me think of plyometrics and one pulsating/ bouncing off the floor, your thoughts Colin?
Plyometrics describes exercises that have an assymetrical or eccentric contraction. If I were to jump off a bench and land lightly on the floor I would be doing plyometrics. In a reverse snap punch, you effectively 'drop' the body relative to the floor whilst still standing on it. The body drop is sent 'forward' into your front foot at the same time your hand hits. Then you snap yourself back to position. This is all done within a small range of motion, but yes, I suppose there is some correlation with plyometric exercises (and that's why they work so well).
"I did this in a recent beginner's class against a kick boxer - showing him the difference between a roundhouse punch, and then this strike done with kime."
I think you just answered a question I had on ‘kime’? You describe it as, “…such strikes done with kime typically encourage me to drop my elbows and keep my feet on the ground.” Isn’t that what a Shotokan practitioner would be looking to do? Anyone...
Yeah, I guess. Most fighters would agree to this though, save for the capoeira guys.
Wow, raising your elbow, is your arm still in alignment at this time? When cresting over the opponent’s guard as you put it, are you looking to score a pint of as Bruce or Tom may put it, fatally injury them?
The arm need not be in linear alignment to transmit power. It is of course more effective when the arm is in an obtuse angle tending towards 180 degrees. But I'm not saying that a roundhouse punch is my preferred way of delivering striking power. I'm just saying that if you're raising your heel off the ground, that's something I would do if I were tactically trying to reach over my opponent's guard.
I wonder how one’s body dynamics, condition changes, if at all at a more advanced level when one raised ones heel off of the ground?
Cheers, Gillian
If you have bypassed hip rotation, and can leverage body mass behind a centreline punch, then I would say you would be able to do the same with your heel lifted off the floor. If however you are lifting your heel to get greater reach, then this is counter to the hip-rotation-kime. Don't you think?
Colin